Question 1

What is 'fully-loaded' employer cost?

Accepted Answer

Fully-loaded employer cost is the total annual amount your business actually spends on a W-2 employee — gross wage plus every employer-side payroll tax, mandatory insurance premium, and benefit. The standard rule of thumb is that a $60,000 wage costs the employer about $72,000–$78,000 fully loaded (a 1.20–1.30x multiplier), but the real number swings on three levers: state SUTA rate and wage base, industry-specific workers' comp class rate, and how rich your benefits package is. This calculator is the verifiable version of that 1.25x rule of thumb. Source: IRS Publication 15 (Circular E), https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-publication-15.

Question 2

What's the difference between FUTA and SUTA?

Accepted Answer

FUTA is federal unemployment tax — 6.0% gross on the first $7,000 of each employee's annual wages, reduced to a 0.6% net rate for employers in states that pay state UI taxes on time (the standard 5.4% credit). That puts the maximum FUTA per employee at $42 per year for almost every employer. SUTA is state unemployment insurance, paid to the state's workforce agency. Rates and wage bases vary widely: California's wage base is $7,000 like FUTA, but Washington's is $67,600. New-employer rates typically run 1–4%; once you have a few years of claims experience, your rate is set by experience-rating (more layoffs = higher rate). Source: U.S. Department of Labor, https://oui.doleta.gov/unemploy/statelaws.asp.

Question 3

Why does construction cost so much more than office work?

Accepted Answer

The single biggest driver is workers' compensation. An office clerical employee (NCCI class 8810) carries a workers' comp rate of roughly 0.30% of payroll — about $180/year on a $60,000 salary. A construction worker on a general construction class code carries a rate around 9% — that same $60,000 salary now adds $5,400 in premium. A roofer (NCCI class 5551) at ~18% adds $10,800. Workers' comp rates reflect actuarial injury risk: a back injury on a roof claim runs into six figures in medical and indemnity costs. The fully-loaded multiplier for a $60K office hire is around 1.10x; for a $60K construction hire it's closer to 1.25x; for a roofer, north of 1.30x. Source: National Council on Compensation Insurance, https://www.ncci.com.

Question 4

Can I just 1099 the person and skip all this?

Accepted Answer

No — and this is the single biggest payroll mistake new business owners make. The IRS's 20-factor common-law test (now consolidated into three categories: behavioral control, financial control, and relationship of the parties) determines worker status. If the worker has set hours, uses your equipment, gets training from you, follows your processes, and works only for you — they are an employee, regardless of what your contract says. Misclassification penalties are severe: the IRS can claw back unpaid employer FICA + FUTA going back three years (or six on willful misclassification), plus interest, plus 100% trust fund recovery penalties on the employee's withholding. State agencies pile on their own SUTA back-assessments. If you're hiring someone who looks anything like an employee, hire them as an employee. Source: IRS Publication 15-A, https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-publication-15-a.

Question 5

How do these annual numbers translate to per-pay-period?

Accepted Answer

The annual numbers in this calculator divide by your pay frequency: 26 for biweekly, 24 for semimonthly, 12 for monthly, 52 for weekly. But two of the components are front-loaded against the year, not evenly distributed. FUTA is paid quarterly via Form 940 (or rolled into the next quarter if the cumulative FUTA owed is under $500). SUTA is paid quarterly via the state's UI agency form. The wage-base caps on Social Security (paid until the YTD wage hits $176,100 in 2026) and SUTA (paid until the YTD wage hits the state's wage base) mean that for high-wage employees, the per-paycheck employer cost is highest in early-year paychecks and drops once the bases are met. Cash-flow planning should use the front-loaded view, not the simple annual ÷ 26. Source: IRS Publication 15.

Question 6

What about state-specific taxes like CA SDI or NY PFL?

Accepted Answer

This calculator covers federal payroll taxes, FUTA, state SUTA, and workers' comp — the universal employer-side costs. It does NOT include state-specific employer obligations that vary widely: California State Disability Insurance (employee-paid, employer-administered); New York Paid Family Leave (mostly employee-paid); New Jersey Temporary Disability/Family Leave (mixed); Washington Paid Family & Medical Leave; Colorado FAMLI; Massachusetts PFML; Oregon Paid Leave. It also doesn't include local payroll taxes (NYC's MCTMT for employers in the metro region, San Francisco's gross receipts tax, Cleveland and Philadelphia local wage taxes, etc.). Add 0.5–2% of payroll to the fully-loaded number for these in CA, NY, NJ, MA, and WA. Confirm with a payroll provider or your state DOL.

Question 7

Do I need workers' comp for one employee?

Accepted Answer

In most states, yes — even one W-2 employee triggers a workers' comp insurance requirement. Texas is the major exception (private-employer workers' comp is technically optional, though employers who opt out lose major liability defenses). Most other states require coverage from the first employee in some industries (construction, agriculture, domestic work) and from the second or third in others. Failing to carry required coverage typically exposes you to: (1) an injured employee suing for tort damages with employer common-law defenses stripped, (2) state stop-work orders, (3) fines that can hit five figures, and (4) personal liability piercing through your LLC's protection in some states. Get a quote before the first day of work. Source: state DOL or Workers' Compensation Board websites.

Question 8

What is the FUTA credit and how does it work?

Accepted Answer

FUTA's headline rate is 6.0% on the first $7,000 of wages — $420 per employee per year if you got no credit. But employers in states whose unemployment insurance program is in good standing receive a 5.4% credit, dropping the effective FUTA rate to 0.6% (the $42 number you see on most employer cost sheets). The credit is automatic if your state pays its federal UI loans on time. When a state has outstanding federal UI loans for two consecutive years (a 'credit reduction state'), the credit shrinks by 0.3% per year until repaid — California in the early 2010s and the Virgin Islands in recent years are the canonical examples. The DOL publishes the annual credit reduction list each November. This calculator assumes the standard credit; if your state appears on the credit-reduction list, manually add the difference to FUTA. Source: IRS Form 940 instructions, https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-940.

Payroll Tax Calculator (First Hire)

Key facts

What this means

Worked example

Frequently asked questions

Show the math